Framework for discussing and reconciling divergent values in multi-disciplinary settings

Themes: Social Impact

 


A TRL is a measure to indicate the matureness of a developing technology. When an innovative idea is discovered it is often not directly suitable for application. Usually such novel idea is subjected to further experimentation, testing and prototyping before it can be implemented. The image below shows how to read TRL’s to categorise the innovative ideas.

Click to enlarge

Summary of the project


Discussing her research on value creation by architects with people from other disciplines, the researcher noticed she had to explain a lot on values. She realised that although the same word was used – values – it had different meanings and implications in different contexts. Values can refer to ideals of people, and as guiding principles influence their choices; but also as qualities that can be co-created and that represent a certain amount of worth. When actors from diverse disciplines collaborate, an awareness of these different perspectives towards values can help to find common ground and avoid miscommunication or confusion in the co-creation process.

By integrating theories from multiple scholarly domains and complementing this with information on how values are being used in practice, the researcher is therefore building a framework that maps out different types of values for various perspectives. Testing the framework in an interdisciplinary project meeting showed that the focus on values created insight and understanding for the positions and actions of the team members. Leading the team to conclude they should have discussed values more explicit and earlier in the collaboration process. 

What's next?


To move this innovative idea forward the researcher would like to perform an extensive literature review to bring together knowledge on value research from different disciplines. Subsequently, the researcher would like to work on developing a method for how the framework can be used for education and in design processes so the different perspectives on values can be taken into account. 

dr. Marina Bos- de Vos

 

dr. Steffen Steinert

Delft Design for Values Institute

Dr. Rob Remis

Faculties involved

  • Industrial Design & Engineering (IDE)
  • Technology, Policy & Management